Pan & Peel Pizza

About Us

Pan and Peel Pizza in Pearl River, NY is dedicated to providing delicious pizza, appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and desserts in a friendly, casual atmosphere. We aim to achieve this by using high-quality ingredients and preparing them with time-tested traditional techniques.

Our Pizza

At Pan and Peel Pizza, we’re deeply inspired by the legendary pizzerias of Naples, Italy, and the iconic New York pizza tradition. Our aim is to create a pizza that captures the fresh, vibrant flavors of Neapolitan pizza while preserving the structure and crispness found in the best New York pies.

It all begins with our dough, mixed by hand using unbleached, unbromated flour at 80% hydration and fermented for several days. The result is a crust that’s light, airy, crispy, and easy to digest. For our sauce, we use whole peeled tomatoes imported from Italy, and we make fresh mozzarella in-house daily to ensure optimal freshness and flavor.

More Than Just Pizza

Starters

We take great pride in providing our guests with an exceptional dining experience from start to finish. Our salads are made with the freshest produce available and topped with house-made dressings. Our mozzarella sticks are crafted in-house using the same fresh mozzarella we make daily. Our fries are hand-cut, cooked in three stages, and never frozen. And our wings are always made fresh, then fried in beef tallow until perfectly crispy. Each of our starters is thoughtfully prepared to showcase our commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and timeless flavor.
Sandwiches

Our sandwiches are crafted with the same dedication to quality and technique that defines everything we serve. Each one is built on bread that is baked fresh to order in-house, ensuring a warm, crisp exterior and tender interior with every bite. Thoughtfully layered with premium ingredients and bold, balanced flavors, our sandwiches offer a satisfying experience that reflects the care and craft at the heart of Pan and Peel.
Dessert

For a sweet finish, we offer our house-made brown butter chocolate chip cookies—rich, decadent, and baked to perfection. For something extra indulgent, enjoy them warm as the foundation of our ice cream sandwich, a comforting and elevated take on a classic treat.