Welcome to Pan and Peel Pizza
Located in the heart of Pearl River, NY, Pan and Peel Pizza is your neighborhood spot for delicious, handcrafted meals in a warm and casual setting. From pizzas and crisp salads to hearty sandwiches, appetizers, and indulgent desserts, every dish is made using high-quality ingredients and time-tested traditional techniques. Join us for comfort food made the right way—fresh, flavorful, and always welcoming.
Our Pizza
At Pan and Peel Pizza, we blend the vibrant flavors of Neapolitan pizza with the crisp structure of classic New York pies. Our dough is mixed by hand with unbleached, unbromated flour, fermented for days to create a light, crispy, and airy crust. We use whole peeled tomatoes from Italy for our sauce and craft fresh mozzarella in-house daily—ensuring every bite is full of authentic, high-quality flavor.
More Than Just Pizza
Our menu goes beyond pizza with house-made starters like hand-cut fries, fresh mozzarella sticks, and wings fried in beef tallow. Enjoy crisp salads with homemade dressings and sandwiches served on fresh-baked bread, layered with bold, quality ingredients. End on a sweet note with our rich brown butter chocolate chip cookies or indulge in a warm ice cream sandwich—crafted for comfort and flavor.
Order Directly From Our Website
Skip the third-party apps and place your order right on our website for the best experience. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pie, fresh salad, crispy wings, or something sweet, it’s all just a few clicks away. Enjoy easy ordering, accurate pickup times, and exclusive online deals—plus, you’re supporting us directly. Fast, simple, and made to order. Start your order today!
A Look at What We’re Serving
Feast your eyes on a selection of our handcrafted menu items—pizzas, fresh salads, crispy wings, sandwiches, and house-made desserts. Each dish is made with care using high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques. Scroll through and see what makes our food as good as it looks.
An Inviting Place to Savor Every Bite
Enjoy a warm and casual setting where quality meets comfort. Whether dining solo or with friends and family, our carefully crafted dishes made from fresh, high-quality ingredients promise a memorable meal. Relax and indulge in classic flavors prepared with time-tested techniques, creating a dining experience that feels like home every time you visit.
📍 Visit Us Today
Come experience delicious, handcrafted meals in a warm and welcoming atmosphere right in the heart of Pearl River. Whether you’re joining us for lunch, dinner, or a casual hangout, we’re ready to serve you with fresh ingredients and time-tested recipes. Stop by and see why we’re the go-to spot for great food and friendly faces.
What our guests are saying
By far the best Pizza in the NYC area, run don't walk. I recommend the burrata and the pepperoni.
Cocomarsh1
Probably the best pizza place in the area hands down. Ate the whole pie in 5 minutes. Doughy light and airy with the crunch, sweet and tangy sauce but not overly sweetened, nice mozzarella blend not too greasy and milky. Reminds me of a South Jersey tomato pie like Maruca's in Seaside heights.
MB
Had a great experience. This place provides the food for the Gentle Giant brewery. Food was great. If you like crispy wings and delicious crispy thin crust pizza, this is the place. I didn’t know what to expect, but was happy my family and I gave it a try. We all enjoyed the food and experience.
David D.
Featuring
Has Outdoor Seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Pan and Peel Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Sandwiches, Mozzarella Sticks, Garlic Knots, White Pizza, Wings, American Food, Salads, Fries, Pie, Dessert, Margherita Pizza, Italian Food, Cheese Pizza, Burrata, Deli Sandwiches, and Vegetarian Food
Where are you located?
We are located in Pearl River, NY at 5 N Main St
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Pearl River, Montvale, Nauraushaun, Park Ridge, Nanuet, Chestnut Ridge, Orangetown, Woodcliff Lake, River Vale, West Nyack, Spring Valley, Old Tappan, Blauvelt, Hillsdale, Upper Saddle River, Tappan, Bardonia, Orangeburg, Central Nyack, Germonds.
Our location
